Consumer Behavior Monitor: When consumers start thinking, A-brands have it tough
Consumers often think they make choices based on reason, but in reality, they usually make choices based on feelings and emotions. This is because a rational choice requires more energy than an emotional one. Consumers are focused on conserving energy. That’s why they operate on autopilot as much as possible. Premium brands make smart use of this by appealing to consumers’ emotions. But what happens when consumers start listening more to their reason, for example, because concerns about privacy or rising prices are growing? In the Consumer Behavior Monitor, an initiative of VU Amsterdam and Validators, we see that when concerns increase, consumers listen more to their reason.
How far are consumers willing to go for premium brands?
As mentioned earlier, consumers make decisions based on gut feeling more often than they realize. This is also true at the supermarket. Many consumers buy premium brands because of their image, because they grew up with them, out of habit, or because they expect better quality. They are happy to pay the premium price for these brands, even though they know that not all premium brands are of higher quality. So, in many cases, it’s a purchase based on emotion. But is there a tipping point where reason takes over from emotion? At a time when more and more consumers are concerned about rising food prices (33%, +5% compared to week 14) and the prices of premium brands are rising significantly, that may well be the case. And this is evident from the Consumer Behavior Monitor. Now that wallets are under pressure, consumers are buying more (cheaper) B-brands en masse (62%, +14% compared to week 14). So while A-brands appeal more to emotion, B-brands appeal more to reason. This is also evident from the quotes we receive from the voice module in the monitor:
“I buy fewer name-brand products, and I check the flyers in advance to see what’s on sale.”
“I pay closer attention to prices at the supermarket, skip the name-brand products, and go for the store brand.”
This breaks long-standing habits. And this can have major consequences for premium brands. Once consumers have switched and continue to use a different product for an extended period, it becomes difficult for premium brands to win them back.
Marcel van Brenk, partner at EY VODW:
We are at a delicate juncture in the market. Consumers are noticing that prices are rising and are accepting this to a certain extent. But we have now reached a point where some brands are in danger of overplaying their hand. Terms like “grabflation” and “shrinkflation” illustrate growing consumer dissatisfaction. Premium brands in particular will need to be vigilant to prevent the shift toward cheaper private labels from continuing. A sophisticated, data-driven pricing and promotional strategy is essential to address this challenge.

Consumers are caught between a rock and a hard place when it comes to privacy.
In addition to concerns about price increases, consumers are also worried about privacy. Concerns about privacy and the processing of personal data have been around for quite some time. Every so often, the issue makes headlines again, only to seem to fade away for a while. Recently, it has been a hot topic again due to the“data hostage situation at the KNVB,” butconcerns about TikTokhave also been around for some time. Consumers appear to be reacting to this. In fact, consumers increasingly consider it important for brands to communicate how they process consumers’ personal data and safeguard its privacy (29%, +7% compared to week 14). Never before has this been so relevant to consumers. But are consumers, just like in the supermarket, also showing a change in behavior as a result? Or is there a true privacy paradox, where consumers say on the one hand that they find their privacy increasingly important, but on the other hand are sharing their personal data more and more?
Convenience wins out over worry
It certainly seems that way. Over the years, consumers have become increasingly comfortable sharing personal data (DDMA Privacy Monitor 2023). Especially when it makes their lives easier or lets them swipe, scroll, and like to their heart’s content. So they’re pretty quick to set their concerns (reason) aside if it brings them convenience or enjoyment (emotion). This explains the privacy paradox: on the one hand, concerns are growing, but on the other, consumers are calmly continuing to share more and more personal data.
TikTok, who's there? Hello, it's Ratio
TikTok has also been in thenewsa lot lately due to its inadequate privacy policies and allegations of espionage. How are consumers reacting to this? Is the privacy paradox rearing its head again? Or is reason finally prevailing over emotion? According to the Consumer Behavior Monitor, there are tentative signs that this is the case. For example, the number of Dutch people who use TikTok at least once a week has dropped to 14% (-8% compared to week 12), and the number who now use TikTok only rarely has risen to 13% (+5% compared to week 14). TikTok usage has therefore declined. Consumers seem to be listening to their heads more than before when considering TikTok usage.

Will consumers now start acting more responsibly and handle their personal data with greater care? Or is this just a temporary scare, and will consumers soon fall back into their old habits? Only time will tell.
This article can also be read on MarketingTribune.
